Guide To Australian Shepherd Training & Care

Electronic Dog Fence vs. Traditional Fencing

An electronic dog fence is an option well worth considering for dog owners. These high tech fences can have many benefits that make them preferable to more traditional fencing. The type of fence you choose for your property will depend on a number of factors including the size and temperament of your dog, the size of your property and the particular surroundings.

Dog Training Videos

The difference between the two types of fence is pretty obvious. Traditional wood, composite or metal fences provide a physical barrier that the dog can see. They also block his view to keep him from knowing what is on the other side of the fence.

An electronic fence consists of a wire that is buried underground, or a wireless system, and a special collar fitted with a transmitter. When the dog gets close to the barrier, the collar transmits a sound or other correction to stop him from going any further.

While both types of fence can work to contain a dog, neither is infallible and the type of fence you choose will depend heavily on the kind of dog you have. More timid dogs may not respond well to the corrections transmitted by an electronic dog fence. For these dogs, traditional fencing may be a better option. This way they can adjust to their boundaries without becoming gun shy.

Red merle Australian Shepherd in yard with wood fence.

everydoghasastory / stock.adobe.com

An electronic dog fence can have advantages over traditional fencing that are worth considering.

Wireless and In-Ground Wired Systems Available on Amazon

PetSafe Wireless Pet Containment System

Extreme Dog Fence DIY Inground Fence for Dogs Complete Static Electric Fence Kit
Wired—Extreme Dog Fence DIY In-Ground Fence for Dogs Complete Static Electric Fence Kit

On the other hand, more active breeds like the Australian Shepherd may be too intelligent and too enthusiastic to be held in by a traditional fence. They are likely to jump over, break through or dig under a traditional fence. For these breeds, the extra control of an electronic fence may actually be a necessity. And because electronic fences can be easily adaptable to fit a larger space, they can also give active breeds more room to run while remaining within safe boundaries.

Advantages Of An Electronic Dog Fence

In fact, that flexibility is one of the bigger advantages of an electronic dog fence. The wires can be placed in almost any pattern, allowing you to choose exactly the size of area you enclose. This can also make it easier to block off areas like gardens, landscaping or water features that you want to keep your dog away from. Also, the ability to bury the wires out of sight means that you can provide the safety your dog needs without taking away from the aesthetics of your property, something many property owners appreciate.

By far the biggest difference between electronic and traditional fencing is cost. Electronic fencing can cost as much as several thousand dollars less than traditional fencing, making it the much more cost effective option, particularly for pet owners with large property. That way you can fence in a much larger area without it costing an arm and a leg.

Another big advantage of an electronic dog fence is avoiding wear and tear. While traditional fences are exposed to the elements and can frequently become damaged, electronic fencing, which is buried under the ground or even wireless, is much more durable. About the only regular maintenance required with electronic fencing is replacing the batteries in the collar transmitter. There may be an occasional need to replace frayed wires but that is infrequent and much less expensive than repairing a traditional fence.

As you can see, both types of fencing can be effective, but electronic fencing does have quite a few advantages that traditional fencing just can't match. The choice will depend on your dog and his specific needs, but ultimately the goal is to keep your best friend safe and give yourself peace of mind.

Australian-Shepherd-Lovers.com icon

Guide To Australian Shepherd Training & Care